BOOKPLATES Publique Deposited
The E-Sylum: Volume 5, Number 47, November 24, 2002, Article 12
BOOKPLATES
George Kolbe writes: "I can't resist making a few observations
on the book inscription responses. I largely agree with Ralf
Böpple's points, though a book, carefully read, might still
properly be described as being in "mint state," it seems to me.
Years ago, I disagreed with a "Letter to the Editor" in a coin
publication which stated that a coin received in commerce
could not be "uncirculated." Technically, that may be so, but
in practice is a coin that displays no signs of wear not likely
to be deemed "mint state"? Ditto a book.In my opinion, circular blindstamps are an abomination. I
like Bookplates (generally the smaller the better) but
adhesive-backed bookplates often contaminate the paper to
which they are attached (much like "scotch tape"). Ideally,
bookplates are unique - I find ones with typed-in owner's
names offputting but maybe I'm a snob. Annotations are
great if the writer knows his subject. Ditto inscriptions
(not "Happy Holidays from Aunt Bess" however estimable
Aunt Bess might be).If you love your books and wish to identify them with an
ex libris, I'd suggest that you spend a few bucks and
commission your own bookplate. I've done two over the
years and will probably one day do another. There are lots
of good bookplate designers out there - or do it yourself
if you have an artistic eye."- 2002-11-24
- 5