1840-O $5

CPG Values (What is CPG?)

Grade CPG Value
F12 $910.00
F15 $960.00
VF20 $1,020.00
VF25 $1,090.00
VF30 $1,180.00
VF35 $1,250.00
XF40 $1,500.00
XF45 $1,880.00
AU50 $2,620.00
AU53 $3,000.00
AU55 $3,500.00
AU58 $5,500.00
MS60 $11,200.00
MS61 $15,300.00
MS62 $26,400.00
MS63 $41,400.00
F12 CAC $1,080.00
F15 CAC $1,140.00
VF20 CAC $1,230.00
VF25 CAC $1,280.00
VF30 CAC $1,390.00
VF35 CAC $1,500.00
XF40 CAC $1,800.00
XF45 CAC $2,500.00
AU50 CAC $3,150.00
AU53 CAC $3,600.00
AU55 CAC $4,500.00
AU58 CAC $6,600.00
MS60 CAC $13,000.00
MS61 CAC $18,400.00
MS62 CAC $31,700.00
MS63 CAC $49,700.00

Apr Data

Auction House Description Grade Sell Price Sell Date
Stacks Bowers 1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-3. Narrow Mill, Small O. Partial Collar. MS-62 (PCGS). 62 $20,400 08/13/24
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS62 PCGS. Variety 3. 62 $19,200 04/23/20
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS62 PCGS. 62 $22,325 10/21/12
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS62 PCGS. Eliasberg-Bass. One of the most intriguing aspects of this coin is what cannot be immediat 62 $25,300 05/07/05
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 PCGS. Variety 2. 55 $5,160 03/29/24
1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-2. Narrow Mill, Large O. AU-55 (PCGS). 55 $6,600 04/06/22
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 PCGS. Variety 3. 55 $2,350 11/01/15
1840-O $5 AU55 PCGS. Variety 3. 55 $3,055 12/08/13
1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. AU Details--Cleaned (PCGS). 0 $3,840 08/23/23
1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-2. Narrow Mill, Large O. EF Details--Graffiti (PCGS). 0 $1,680 06/11/21
1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-2. Narrow Mill. AU Details--Tooled (PCGS). 0 $1,020 12/18/20
1840-O Liberty Half Eagle. AU Details--Tooled (PCGS). 0 $881 03/31/17
1840-O Liberty Half Eagle. Winter Variety Two. Narrow Mill. Genuine--Code 92, Cleaning (PCGS). 0 $562 08/14/11
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU50 PCGS. CAC. Variety 2. 50 $3,360 08/17/23
$5 1840-O PCGS AU50+ CAC 50 $3,525 05/25/23
1840-O $5 PCGS/CAC AU50 50 $2,250 06/22/20
1840-O $5 -- Cleaning -- Narrow Mill AU50 PCGS. PCGS Population: (14/34). NGC Census: (18/92). CDN: $1,800 Whsle. Bid for p 50 $852 07/09/17
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU50 PCGS. Variety 3. 50 $1,998 04/30/17
1840-O $5 AU50 PCGS. Variety 3. 50 $1,998 12/02/12
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU50 PCGS. 50 $2,530 01/09/11
1840-O Liberty Half Eagle. Winter Variety Two. Narrow Mill. AU-50 (PCGS). 50 $2,124 08/07/10
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU50 PCGS. 50 $2,070 12/10/04
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1840-O $5 50 $2,530 05/31/04
American Numismatic Rarities 1840-O $5 50 $2,300 01/05/04
HA 1840-O $5 50 $1,265 08/08/01
HA 1840-O $5 50 $1,840 08/13/99
HA 1840-O $5 50 $1,216 01/07/98
Scotsman 1840-O PCGS XF-40 40 $1,770 07/28/23
1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-3. Narrow Mill, Small O. EF-40 (PCGS). 40 $2,040 05/29/19
1840-O $5 PCGS/CAC XF40 40 $1,425 02/04/19
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF40 PCGS. PCGS Population: (23/76). NGC Census: (9/135). CDN: $950 Whsle. Bid for problem-free NGC/P 40 $1,320 01/14/19
1840-O Liberty Half Eagle. EF-40 (PCGS). 40 $1,081 08/04/12
HA 1840-O $5 40 $852 04/24/98
HA 1840-O $5 40 $561 07/29/97
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF45 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: (23/59). NGC Census: (28/121). CDN: $1,250 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS X 45 $2,280 10/09/22
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF45 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: (25/54). NGC Census: (26/115). CDN: $1,250 Whsle. Bid for problem-fr 45 $2,160 06/09/19
HA 1840-O $5 45 $1,438 01/05/01
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1840-O $5 45 $1,207 10/02/00
HA 1840-O $5 45 $990 03/16/96
HA 1840-O $5 45 $605 02/06/95
1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-2. Narrow Mill, Large O. VF-35 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. 35 $2,280 06/15/22
1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-3. Narrow Mill, Small O. VF-35 (PCGS). CAC. 35 $2,400 08/06/20
1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-2. Narrow Mill, Large O. MS-61 (PCGS). 61 $11,400 08/17/21
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS61 PCGS. Variety 3. 61 $9,106 08/14/16
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS61 PCGS. An Uncirculated example of this popular first year of issue with exquisite, deep yellow-go 61 $10,925 11/05/05
HA 1840-O $5 61 $10,638 08/13/99
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill VF30 PCGS. PCGS Population: (6/106). NGC Census: (2/151). CDN: $700 Whsle. Bid for problem-free NGC/P 30 $1,170 08/18/19
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill VF30 PCGS. PCGS Population (5/97). NGC Census: (2/149). Mintage: 40,120. From The Ohio Valley C 30 $1,880 09/11/16
1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Narrow Mill. AU-58 (PCGS). 58 $3,840 08/18/18
1840-O $5 AU58 PCGS. Variety 2. 58 $4,465 01/09/17
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 PCGS. Variety 3. 58 $8,812 11/02/16
1840-O $5 AU53 PCGS. Variety 3. 53 $2,232 03/23/14
1840-O $5 AU53 PCGS. Variety 3. 53 $2,115 03/24/13
1840-O $5 AU53 PCGS. CAC. Variety 2. 53 $3,450 09/11/11
1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU53 PCGS. Variety 3. 53 $4,888 05/01/11
HA 1840-O $5 63 $31,625 08/07/98
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF40 NGC. NGC Census: (8/150). Mintage 40,120. 40 $1,380 01/13/25
HA 1840-O $5 Broad Mill XF40 NGC. NGC Census: (8/143). PCGS Population: (21/77). CDN: $950 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS XF40. Minta 40 $1,440 03/22/21
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF40 NGC. NGC Census: (9/137). PCGS Population (22/67). Mintage: 40,120. CDN Wsl. Price for problem f 40 $822 09/12/16
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF40 NGC. NGC Census: (9/137). PCGS Population (22/67). Mintage: 40,120. CDN Wsl. Price for problem f 40 $1,880 09/11/16
HA 1840-O $5 Large Diameter XF40 NGC. NGC Census: (9/121). PCGS Population (19/53). Mintage: 40,120. Numismedia Wsl. Price for 40 $1,610 01/16/08
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF40 NGC. Scarcer in higher grades, this coin is pleasing in overall appearance and striking characte 40 $978 02/11/06
HA 1840-O $5 40 $1,208 06/06/98
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. Variety 3. The 1 in the date is centered over a dentil and heavy die lines exist between I 55 $2,778 02/13/23
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. NGC Census: (34/49). PCGS Population: (13/19). CDN: $2,600 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS AU55. Mi 55 $2,760 05/18/22
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. Variety 3. 55 $2,520 08/16/19
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. Variety 3. 55 $1,740 03/15/19
Stacks Bowers 1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Small O, Small Diameter. AU-55 (NGC). 55 $1,740 03/01/19
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1840-O $5 NGC AU55 (Small Diameter) 55 $2,550 07/10/17
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. Variety 3. 55 $2,009 05/01/16
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. Variety 2. 55 $1,762 02/01/15
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. Variety 2. 55 $1,762 08/09/14
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. Variety 3. 55 $1,998 08/09/14
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. NGC Census: (27/40). PCGS Population (7/14). Mintage: 40,120. Numismedia Wsl. Price for pro 55 $2,291 10/30/12
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. NGC Census: (4/37). PCGS Population (7/14). Mintage: 40,120. Numismedia Wsl. Price for prob 55 $2,070 11/16/10
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU55 NGC. 55 $1,610 01/11/09
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1840-O $5 55 $2,128 02/10/08
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1840-O $5 Small Diameter NGC AU55 55 $2,272 10/22/07
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1840-O $5 55 $2,128 05/30/05
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1840-O $5 55 $2,185 02/20/05
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1840-O $5 NGC AU55 55 $2,645 07/21/04
HA 1840-O $5 AU55 NGC. The New Orleans Mint delivered a 55 $1,840 09/28/02
HA 1840-O $5 55 $1,760 03/16/96
HA 1840-O $5 55 $1,210 01/04/95
Stacks Bowers 1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-2. Narrow Mill, Large O. AU-58 (NGC). 58 $3,240 03/26/21
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. NGC Census: (29/19). PCGS Population: (9/8). CDN: $4,000 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS AU58. Mint 58 $4,320 03/22/21
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. Variety 2. 58 $3,120 10/18/19
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. 58 $3,120 09/06/19
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. Variety 3. 58 $4,320 02/22/18
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. Variety 3. 58 $5,405 06/07/15
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. Variety 3. 58 $3,408 09/06/14
HA 1840-O $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 2. 58 $2,820 01/14/13
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. Variety 3. 58 $3,450 09/11/11
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1840-O $5 58 $2,990 05/25/08
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. 58 $3,450 09/28/07
Superior 1840-O $5 58 $2,588 11/16/06
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. Breen-6530, Medium Oval O. 21.65 mm. The Narrow Mill 1840-O is an important condition rarit 58 $3,738 07/08/06
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. The 1840-O had a rather substantial mintage of 40,120 pieces. However, Choice AU examples a 58 $2,990 01/07/06
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1840-O $5 58 $3,105 05/31/04
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. The 1840-O had a rather 58 $2,990 01/11/03
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU58 NGC. A near-Mint example of 58 $2,415 11/25/02
HA 1840-O $5 58 $2,645 06/10/00
HA 1840-O $5 58 $3,220 01/07/00
HA 1840-O $5 58 $2,090 08/17/96
Stacks Bowers 1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-3. Narrow Mill, Small O. AU-50 (NGC). 50 $1,620 03/26/21
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU50 NGC. Variety 2. The usual Narrow Mill reverse variant, this variety with the Large O mintmar 50 $1,740 02/09/21
Stacks Bowers 1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-1. Broad Mill. AU-50 (NGC). 50 $2,760 12/18/20
HA 1840-O $5 Broad Mill AU50 NGC. This is the Broad Mill variety (NGC calls it Large Diameter). According to Doug Winter on Co 50 $5,100 08/09/20
Stacks Bowers 1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Broad Mill. AU-50 (NGC). 50 $1,762 06/27/17
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill -- Improperly Cleaned -- NCS. AU Details. NGC Census: (16/82). PCGS Population (13/31). Mintage: 40,1 50 $734 12/08/13
HA 1840-O $5 AU50 NGC. Variety 2. 50 $1,322 08/14/11
HA 1840-O $5 Broad Mill AU50 NGC. 50 $1,495 07/12/09
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1840-O $5 NGC Small Diameter AU50 50 $1,438 04/23/07
HA 1840-O $5 50 $1,782 04/23/99
Stacks Bowers 1840-O Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter-2. Narrow Mill, Large O. AU Details--Rim Filing (NGC). 0 $2,400 03/26/21
Scotsman 1840-O, 1849-C, and an 1852-C, all NGC XF detail, as described 0 $3,910 07/29/16
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU53 NGC. NGC Census: (19/80). PCGS Population: (11/29). CDN: $2,100 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS AU53. Mi 53 $2,042 03/22/21
HA 1840-O $5 AU53 NGC. Variety 3. 53 $1,998 09/06/14
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill AU53 NGC. 53 $1,610 10/31/10
HA 1840-O $5 Broad Mill AU53 NGC. 53 $2,645 04/19/08
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1840-O $5 NGC AU53 53 $1,495 05/15/06
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill VF30 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (2/154). PCGS Population: (5/107). CDN: $700 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS VF30. 30 $1,440 03/22/21
HA 1840-O $5 Broad Mill VF30 NGC. 30 $756 09/21/08
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF45 NGC. NGC Census: (26/115). PCGS Population: (25/53). CDN: $1,250 Whsle. Bid for problem-free NGC 45 $1,110 06/09/19
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF45 NGC. NGC Census: (24/98). PCGS Population (23/44). Mintage: 40,120. Numismedia Wsl. Price for pr 45 $1,234 09/03/13
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill XF45 NGC. 45 $978 09/21/08
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1840-O $5 NGC XF45 45 $1,150 04/21/08
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1840-O $5 NGC XF45 45 $968 03/31/08
Superior 1840-O $5 45 $1,150 05/27/03
HA 1840-O $5 45 $715 10/07/95
HA 1840-O $5 45 $869 06/03/94
HA 1840-O $5 45 $1,155 05/06/94
HA 1840-O $5 45 $660 04/08/94
HA 1840-O $5 45 $715 03/04/94
HA 1840-O $5 45 $880 01/05/94
HA 1840-O $5 45 $660 01/05/94
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS61 NGC. Variety 3. 61 $7,638 11/10/14
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS61 NGC. Variety 3. 61 $8,812 08/09/14
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS61 NGC. Variety 3. 61 $9,988 04/27/14
HA 1840-O $5 Broad Mill MS61 NGC. 61 $12,650 02/08/09
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS61 NGC. 61 $7,532 12/10/04
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill MS63 NGC. 63 $34,500 09/28/07
HA 1840-O $5 Narrow Mill VF35 NGC. NGC Census: (6/117). PCGS Population (4/69). Mintage: 40,120. Numismedia Wsl. Price: $568. 35 $978 05/14/07
NNP Encyclopedia data is provided in cooperation of Collectibles Technology Corporation (CTC) and CDN Publishing, LLC. NNP assumes no liability or accuracy of this data.

NNP is 100% non-profit and independent

Your feedback is essential and welcome