1842-D $5 Small Date

CPG Values (What is CPG?)

Grade CPG Value
F12 $1,940.00
F15 $2,060.00
VF20 $2,250.00
VF25 $2,380.00
VF30 $2,560.00
VF35 $2,750.00
XF40 $3,000.00
XF45 $3,500.00
AU50 $5,000.00
AU53 $5,500.00
AU55 $7,190.00
AU58 $9,380.00
MS60 $15,600.00
MS61 $18,000.00
MS62 $24,000.00
MS63 $39,000.00
F12 CAC $2,320.00
F15 CAC $2,480.00
VF20 CAC $2,700.00
VF25 CAC $2,850.00
VF30 CAC $3,080.00
VF35 CAC $3,300.00
XF40 CAC $3,600.00
XF45 CAC $4,200.00
AU50 CAC $6,000.00
AU53 CAC $6,600.00
AU55 CAC $8,620.00
AU58 CAC $11,200.00
MS60 CAC $18,700.00
MS61 CAC $21,600.00
MS62 CAC $28,800.00
MS63 CAC $46,800.00

Apr Data

Auction House Description Grade Sell Price Sell Date
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF-45 (PCGS). 45 $4,560 12/18/24
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF-45 (PCGS). CAC. 45 $5,040 11/21/23
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF-45+ (PCGS). 45 $3,960 08/09/23
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF-45 (PCGS). CAC. 45 $4,440 03/22/23
1842-D $5 Small Date XF45 PCGS. Gold CAC. Variety 7-E. Most 1842-D half eagles known are of the Small Date variety, however 45 $6,600 02/13/23
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF-45 (PCGS). CAC. 45 $4,560 08/25/22
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF-45 (PCGS). 45 $3,360 08/25/22
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF-45 (PCGS). 45 $2,640 08/19/21
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date. EF-45 (PCGS). 45 $2,880 08/06/20
1842-D $5 Small Date XF45 PCGS. Variety 7-E. 45 $2,350 07/13/14
1842-D $5 Small Date XF45 PCGS. Variety 8-E. 45 $2,232 01/14/13
1842-D Liberty Half Eagle. Small Date. EF-45 (PCGS). 45 $2,973 08/10/12
Scotsman 1842-D $5 Small Date 45 $2,185 07/27/12
1842-D $5 Small Date XF45 PCGS. Variety 8-E. 45 $2,300 11/10/11
1842-D $5 Small Date XF45 PCGS. Variety 8-E. 45 $2,588 10/31/10
1842-D $5 Small Date PCGS XF45 45 $2,185 04/23/07
Superior 1842-D $5 Small Date 45 $1,955 05/27/01
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 45 $3,220 10/04/00
R.M. Smythe 1842-D $5 Small Date 45 $4,500 05/01/00
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-55 (PCGS). 55 $6,600 08/17/24
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E, the only known dies. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-55 (PCGS). CAC. 55 $8,400 08/23/22
1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 PCGS. Variety 7-E. 55 $4,104 01/11/19
1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 PCGS. Variety 7-E. 55 $3,995 11/01/15
Stacks Bowers 1842-D $5 Small Date 55 $8,625 09/19/06
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 PCGS. 55 $5,175 01/15/05
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 55 $9,680 07/30/94
1842-D $5 Small Date VF25 PCGS. PCGS Population: (13/190 and 0/2+). NGC Census: (6/157 and 0/0+). CDN: $1,900 Whsle. Bid fo 25 $2,760 09/17/23
1842-D $5 Small Date VF25 PCGS. PCGS Population: (12/185 and 0/1+). NGC Census: (6/154 and 0/0+). CDN: $1,725 Whsle. Bid fo 25 $2,100 10/13/21
1842-D $5 Small Date VF25 PCGS. Variety 8-E. 25 $1,438 08/15/10
1842-D $5 Small Date VF25 PCGS. 25 $1,955 12/06/09
Scotsman 1842-D $5 Small Date 25 $1,552 10/16/09
HA Multiple Coin Lot 25 $1,006 08/07/98
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. 58 $7,800 11/04/22
1842-D $5 Small Date AU58 PCGS. Variety 8-E. 58 $6,462 01/14/13
1842-D $5 Small Date AU58 PCGS. Variety 6-E. 58 $6,900 05/01/11
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU58 PCGS. 58 $6,325 12/10/04
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU58 PCGS. Winter 6-E, the only 58 $5,750 05/03/03
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 58 $7,425 03/18/98
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 58 $4,290 02/06/95
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF Details--Tooled (PCGS). 0 $2,040 11/02/22
1842-D Liberty Half Eagle. Small Date. AU Details--Graffiti (PCGS). 0 $1,292 08/11/16
1842-D Liberty Half Eagle. Small Date. AU Details--Filed Rims (PCGS). 0 $1,645 08/08/14
1842-D Liberty Half Eagle. Small Date. Winter 7-E. Genuine--Code 94, Altered Surfaces (PCGS). 0 $4,100 08/19/11
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. MS-62 (PCGS). 62 $26,400 08/25/22
Superior 1842-D $5 Small Date 62 $13,668 08/12/06
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1842-D $5 Small Date 62 $14,375 02/05/06
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date MS62 PCGS. Small Date and Small 62 $14,950 01/10/04
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date MS62 PCGS. Winter 6-E. This is the 62 $13,800 01/11/03
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 62 $17,250 02/12/99
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 62 $18,975 01/08/99
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-53 (PCGS). CAC. 53 $6,000 08/25/22
1842-D Liberty Half Eagle. Small Date. AU-53 (PCGS). CAC. 53 $5,405 03/31/17
1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 PCGS. Variety 7-E. 53 $3,642 01/09/17
1842-D $5 PCGS/CAC AU53 (Small Date) 53 $4,300 08/15/16
1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 PCGS. CAC. Variety 7-E. 53 $4,230 03/06/16
1842-D Liberty Half Eagle. Small Date. AU-53 (PCGS). 53 $5,868 03/15/13
Superior 1842-D $5 Small Date 53 $4,313 01/02/06
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 PCGS. 53 $3,565 11/06/04
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 53 $2,360 04/05/01
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 53 $2,310 08/19/95
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 53 $2,420 06/04/95
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-50 (PCGS). 50 $4,080 08/25/22
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-50 (PCGS). CAC. 50 $7,200 04/06/22
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-50 (PCGS). 50 $5,040 03/26/21
1842-D $5 Small Date AU50 PCGS. Variety 7-E. 50 $3,349 07/09/17
American Numismatic Rarities 1842-D $5 Small Date 50 $2,645 08/11/06
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 50 $1,980 10/04/95
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. VF-35 (PCGS). 35 $2,880 08/25/22
1842-D $5 Small Date VF35 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: (20/150 and 0/1+). NGC Census: (4/135 and 0/0+). CDN: $1,850 Whsle. B 35 $3,360 08/22/21
1842-D $5 Small Date VF35 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: (20/147 and 0/1+). NGC Census: (4/134 and 0/0+). CDN: $1,850 Whsle. B 35 $2,400 10/18/20
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Small Date. VF-35 (PCGS). 35 $1,800 03/23/18
1842-D $5 Small Date VF35 PCGS. Variety 8-E. 35 $1,782 09/11/11
1842-D $5 Small Date VF35 PCGS. 35 $1,668 12/06/09
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 35 $605 02/03/93
1842-D $5 Small Date VF30 PCGS. Variety 7-E. 30 $2,160 12/13/18
1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Small Date. VF-30 (PCGS). CAC. 30 $2,160 08/18/18
1842-D $5 Small Date VF30 PCGS. 30 $1,495 03/31/09
1842-D $5 Small Date VF30 PCGS. 30 $1,840 06/02/08
1842-D $5 Small Date XF40 PCGS Secure. Variety 7-E. 40 $2,280 06/15/18
1842-D $5 PCGS XF40 (Small Date) 40 $2,185 04/22/10
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF40 PCGS. Winter 6-E. More 40 $1,725 05/31/03
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 40 $962 06/04/95
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 40 $990 03/04/95
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 40 $935 01/06/93
1842-D $5 Small Date MS60 PCGS. Variety 7-H. 60 $11,400 04/26/18
1842-D $5 Small Date AG3 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: (2/189). NGC Census: (0/158). Mintage 59,608. 3 $822 04/06/17
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date MS61 PCGS. Ex: Chestatee. Winter 6-E. 61 $12,650 01/11/03
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 61 $12,075 08/13/99
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date VG8 NGC. NGC Census: (2/175). Mintage 59,608. 8 $2,280 08/26/24
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date VG8 NGC. NGC Census: (1/145). PCGS Population (1/164). Mintage: 59,608. (#8210) 8 $719 03/20/11
HA 1842-D $5 VG Details, Scratched, NCS. Variety 8-E. Incorrectly designated as a Quarter Eagle by NCS. A well circulated stra 8 $460 06/03/05
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date VF25 NGC. NGC Census: (6/160). Mintage 59,608. 25 $2,640 08/18/24
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. VF-25 (NGC). OH. 25 $2,760 06/18/24
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. VF-25 (NGC). 25 $2,040 04/07/22
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date. VF-25 (NGC). 25 $1,587 06/18/10
Stacks Bowers 1842-D $5 Small Date 25 $1,495 07/30/09
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date VF25 NGC. 25 $1,610 05/03/09
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date VF25 NGC. 25 $1,265 03/31/09
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 NGC. Variety 7-E. 53 $4,440 05/10/24
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1842-D $5 NGC/CAC AU53 (Small Date OH) 53 $6,750 11/07/22
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-53 (NGC). 53 $4,080 08/25/22
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 NGC. Variety 7-E. 53 $3,120 04/24/20
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 NGC. Variety 7-E. 53 $3,055 09/12/16
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 NGC. Variety 7-E. 53 $3,760 04/26/15
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1842-D $5 Small Date 53 $2,360 06/01/14
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 NGC. Variety 7-E. 53 $2,820 02/05/14
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 NGC. Variety 8-E. 53 $4,112 04/28/13
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU53 NGC. 53 $2,300 03/31/09
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF45 NGC. Variety 7-E. 45 $3,480 10/07/22
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF-45 (NGC). 45 $3,720 06/15/22
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1842-D $5 NGC XF45 (Small Date) 45 $2,975 11/23/20
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF45 NGC. Variety 7-E. 45 $2,115 12/07/14
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1842-D $5 Small Date 45 $2,300 06/02/13
Superior 1842-D $5 Small Date 45 $1,919 08/12/06
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. Variety 7-E. 55 $5,760 08/26/22
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-55 (NGC). CAC. 55 $5,520 08/25/22
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. AU-55 (NGC). 55 $4,080 08/19/21
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. CAC. Variety 7-E. Ex: Rive d'Or Collection. The Small Date 1842-D half eagle is the more ple 55 $4,320 03/08/20
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. Variety 7-E. 55 $4,814 01/10/20
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. Variety 7-E. 55 $3,480 04/26/19
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. Variety 7-E. 55 $3,760 08/04/17
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. Variety 7-E. 55 $3,966 09/06/14
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. 55 $4,112 01/12/14
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1842-D $5 NGC AU55 (Small Date) 55 $3,910 05/17/10
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. 55 $3,177 10/25/08
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. Variety 8-E. The 1842-D Small Date is relatively common in terms of its overall rarity, but 55 $3,220 04/07/06
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1842-D $5 Small Date NGC AU55 55 $6,038 07/21/04
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU55 NGC. While not as great a 55 $2,645 04/28/02
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 55 $2,310 08/19/95
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 7-E. Small Date, Small Letters. EF-40 (NGC). CAC. 40 $2,880 08/25/22
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF40 NGC. Variety 7-E. 40 $1,939 12/08/13
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF40 NGC. Variety 8-E. 40 $1,880 01/14/13
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF40 NGC. Variety 8-E. 40 $1,880 12/02/12
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF40 NGC. NGC Census: (16/106). PCGS Population (23/92). Mintage: 59,608. Numismedia Wsl. Price for NG 40 $1,840 09/27/09
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF40 NGC. 40 $1,725 07/12/09
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date--Obverse Rim Filed--NCS. XF Details. 40 $1,380 07/13/07
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF40 NGC. Variety 8-E. Noticeably abraded surfaces with vivid green-gold coloration. Quite weakly defi 40 $1,955 01/07/06
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date XF Details, Mount Removed, Bent, NCS. Variety 8-E. Moderately worn, for the grade, with somewhat gloss 40 $1,380 07/30/05
Superior 1842-D $5 Small Date 40 $1,150 10/01/00
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Half Eagle. Small Date. AU Details--Cleaned, Reverse Damage (NGC). 0 $1,410 03/31/17
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1842-D $5 Small Date 0 $920 09/06/11
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1842-D $5 NGC AU58 (Small Date) 58 $5,290 03/27/17
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU58 NGC. Variety 8-E. 58 $5,052 04/28/13
Stacks Bowers 1842-D Liberty Half Eagle. Small Date. AU-58 (NGC). 58 $5,740 03/23/12
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU58 NGC. 58 $4,312 05/03/09
Stacks Bowers 1842-D $5 Small Date 58 $5,980 10/11/07
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU58 NGC. Variety 8-E. The Small Date variant is the last of the previous years' date and lettering si 58 $4,600 01/06/07
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU58 NGC. Variety 8-E. A crisply struck straw-gold Dahlonega half eagle that benefits from a remarkabl 58 $4,888 07/08/06
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1842-D $5 Small Date 58 $5,894 05/28/06
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1842-D $5 Small Date 58 $5,520 05/30/05
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 58 $4,140 08/02/97
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU50 NGC. Variety 7-E. 50 $3,525 09/12/16
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date--Rev Damaged--NCS. AU Details. NGC Census: (10/65). PCGS Population (15/43). Mintage: 59,608. Numismed 50 $1,325 07/13/10
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date AU Details, Improperly Cleaned, NCS. Variety 7-E. Well struck for a Dahlonega product, this specimen 50 $2,070 09/24/05
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 50 $2,310 08/16/95
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date VF30 NGC. Variety 7-E. 30 $1,645 09/11/16
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date VF30 NGC. 30 $1,840 03/07/08
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date -- Scratched -- NCS. Fine Details. NGC Census: (2/145). PCGS Population (1/175). Mintage: 59,608. Numi 12 $764 01/12/15
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date MS62 NGC. Variety 7-E. 62 $16,450 04/27/14
Stacks Bowers 1842-D $5 Small Date 62 $15,812 10/11/07
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date MS62 NGC. Variety 6-E. Coruscating, full mint luster emanates from the sunset-orange surfaces of this 62 $17,825 08/14/06
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date MS62 NGC. Small Date and Small 62 $13,800 01/31/04
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1842-D $5 Small Date 62 $14,375 09/23/02
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date VF20 NGC. Variety 8-E. 20 $1,575 08/05/12
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date MS61 NGC. Variety 8-E. 61 $10,350 06/03/12
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1842-D $5 Small Date 61 $10,638 01/29/12
HA 1842-D $5 SM DATE 61 $9,775 01/10/98
HA 1842-D $5 Small Date VF35 NGC. 35 $1,725 11/07/07
NNP Encyclopedia data is provided in cooperation of Collectibles Technology Corporation (CTC) and CDN Publishing, LLC. NNP assumes no liability or accuracy of this data.

NNP is 100% non-profit and independent

Your feedback is essential and welcome