1858-D $5

CPG Values (What is CPG?)

Grade CPG Value
VF20 $2,500.00
VF25 $2,750.00
VF30 $3,000.00
VF35 $3,120.00
XF40 $3,250.00
XF45 $3,750.00
AU50 $4,120.00
AU53 $5,000.00
AU55 $6,500.00
AU58 $8,750.00
MS60 $14,400.00
MS61 $19,200.00
MS62 $31,200.00
MS63 $67,200.00
VF20 CAC $3,000.00
VF25 CAC $3,300.00
VF30 CAC $3,600.00
VF35 CAC $3,750.00
XF40 CAC $3,900.00
XF45 CAC $4,500.00
AU50 CAC $4,950.00
AU53 CAC $6,000.00
AU55 CAC $7,800.00
AU58 CAC $10,500.00
MS60 CAC $17,300.00
MS61 CAC $23,000.00
MS62 CAC $37,400.00
MS63 CAC $80,600.00

Apr Data

Auction House Description Grade Sell Price Sell Date
1858-D $5 AU50 PCGS. Winter 43-HH. 50 $5,062 01/17/25
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-II. AU-50 (PCGS). 50 $4,800 11/21/23
1858-D $5 PCGS/CAC AU50 50 $6,760 10/18/21
1858-D $5 PCGS/CAC AU50 (OGH) 50 $4,800 09/13/21
1858-D $5 AU50 PCGS. Variety 43-HH. 50 $3,360 09/07/18
1858-D $5 AU50 PCGS. Variety 43-HH. 50 $2,820 08/04/17
1858-D $5 AU50 PCGS. CAC. Variety 43-II. 50 $3,525 05/01/16
HA 1858-D $5 50 $2,185 10/04/01
HA 1858-D $5 50 $3,105 01/08/99
HA 1858-D $5 50 $2,415 08/07/98
HA 1858-D $5 50 $1,622 08/19/95
HA 1858-D $5 50 $1,760 03/04/95
HA 1858-D $5 50 $1,925 04/08/94
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-HH. AU Details--Cleaned (PCGS). 0 $3,840 11/21/24
1858-D Liberty Half Eagle. EF Details--Cleaning (PCGS). 0 $1,645 03/31/17
Stacks Bowers 1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-HH. AU-55 (PCGS). CAC. 55 $7,200 08/17/24
1858-D $5 AU55 PCGS Gold Shield. CAC. Variety 43-HH. 55 $4,920 01/31/19
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. AU-55 (PCGS). CAC. 55 $5,040 08/18/18
1858-D $5 AU55 PCGS. Variety 42-HH (formerly 35-DD). 55 $3,525 04/28/13
1858-D Liberty Half Eagle. AU-55 (PCGS). 55 $8,108 08/10/12
Stacks Bowers 1858-D $5 55 $4,600 01/26/11
Stacks Bowers 1858-D $5 55 $3,450 11/13/07
1858-D $5 AU55 PCGS. 55 $3,450 11/07/07
1858-D $5 AU55 PCGS. Variety 35-CC. An issue from late in the life of the Dahlonega Mint, which saw declining mintages ever 55 $3,220 05/12/07
HA 1858-D AU55 PCGS. 55 $4,140 10/07/03
HA 1858-D $5 AU55 PCGS. Noted branch mint gold expert 55 $3,105 07/30/02
HA 1858-D $5 55 $4,370 01/12/02
HA 1858-D $5 55 $2,585 05/22/93
Scotsman 1858-D PCGS XF-45 (green label) 45 $4,838 07/28/23
1858-D $5 XF45 PCGS. Variety 43-HH. 45 $2,400 09/07/18
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. EF-45 (PCGS). CAC. 45 $2,760 11/10/17
1858-D $5 XF45 PCGS. Variety 43-HH. 45 $2,350 05/01/16
1858-D Liberty Half Eagle. EF-45 (PCGS). OGH--First Generation. 45 $4,501 11/08/13
1858-D $5 XF45 PCGS. Variety 35-CC. Significant peripheral luster remains on the obverse, and the reverse fields have a tra 45 $5,462 01/06/07
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-II. EF-40 (PCGS). CAC. 40 $3,840 03/22/23
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 35-DD. Large D. EF-40 (PCGS). CAC. 40 $3,360 03/26/21
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 35-DD. Large D. EF-40 (PCGS). CAC. 40 $3,120 08/06/20
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. EF-40 (PCGS). 40 $1,920 06/22/18
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-HH. AU-53 (PCGS). CAC. 53 $7,200 11/02/22
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 35-DD. Large D. AU-53 (PCGS). CAC. 53 $12,000 04/06/22
1858-D $5 AU53 PCGS. Variety 42-GG (formerly 35-CC). 53 $4,112 02/10/13
1858-D $5 AU53 PCGS. Variety 35-CC. 53 $4,456 06/03/12
American Numismatic Rarities 1858-D $5 53 $3,220 08/11/06
HA 1858-D $5 AU53 PCGS. Noted branch mint gold expert 53 $6,325 03/27/04
HA 1858-D $5 53 $2,310 03/12/93
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-HH. AU-58 (PCGS). 58 $7,500 08/25/22
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-HH. AU-58 (PCGS). 58 $8,400 08/23/22
1858-D $5 AU58 PCGS. Variety 43-HH. 58 $5,640 10/17/19
$5 1858-D PCGS AU58 CAC 58 $7,638 03/21/19
1858-D $5 AU58 PCGS. Variety 43-HH. 58 $7,638 04/27/14
1858-D $5 AU58 PCGS. Variety 43-II (formerly 35-DD). 58 $4,112 01/12/14
1858-D $5 AU58 PCGS. Variety 42-GG (formerly 35-CC). 58 $5,581 08/10/13
1858-D Liberty Half Eagle. Medium D. AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. 58 $6,756 11/16/12
1858-D Liberty Half Eagle. AU-58 (PCGS). 58 $6,943 11/18/11
Stacks Bowers 1858-D $5 58 $7,475 06/15/10
1858-D $5 AU58 PCGS. 58 $6,038 09/13/09
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 PCGS. Variety 35-DD. An challenging late- 58 $6,095 08/21/04
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-HH. VF-30 (PCGS). OGH--First Generation. 30 $3,360 06/15/22
1858-D $5 VF30 PCGS. Variety 35-DD. 30 $2,186 07/15/12
HA 1858-D $5 30 $578 02/05/94
1858-D $5 MS63 PCGS. Variety 43-HH. 63 $60,000 05/05/22
1858-D $5 MS62+ PCGS. Variety 43-HH. 62 $22,800 04/24/21
1858-D $5 MS62 PCGS. Variety 35-CC. 62 $21,850 04/22/12
1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 35-DD. Large D. VF-25 (PCGS). CAC. 25 $2,220 11/13/20
1858-D Liberty Half Eagle. MS-61 (PCGS). CAC. 61 $15,275 08/14/15
1858-D $5 MS61 PCGS. Variety 43-HH, 61 $9,988 03/01/15
1858-D $5 MS61 PCGS. Variety 43-HH. 61 $7,638 08/09/14
1858-D $5 MS61 PCGS. CAC. Variety 42-GG. 61 $17,625 06/09/13
HA 1858-D $5 MS61 PCGS. Large mintmark. Variety 35-DD. (per 61 $12,075 01/10/04
HA 1858-D $5 61 $11,500 08/13/99
HA 1858-D $5 61 $9,430 01/08/99
R.M. Smythe 1858-D $5 35 $1,300 05/01/00
HA 1858-D $5 10 $402 09/13/97
Stacks Bowers 1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-II. AU Details--Obverse Damage (NGC). 0 $2,280 06/18/24
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1858-D $5 0 $2,128 01/29/12
HA 1858-D $5 MS62+ NGC. Variety 43-HH. 62 $18,600 03/28/24
HA 1858-D $5 MS62+ NGC. Variety 43-HH. 62 $16,800 11/20/20
HA 1858-D $5 VF25 NGC. CAC. Variety 43-II. Ex: Long Island Collection. Smooth, moderately worn surfaces display pleasing olive 25 $3,240 02/13/23
HA 1858-D $5 VF25 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (2/109). PCGS Population: (6/124). CDN: $1,850 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS VF25. Mintage 1 25 $3,480 02/27/22
Stacks Bowers 1858-D Liberty Head Half Eagle. Winter 43-HH. AU-55 (NGC). 55 $4,560 11/04/22
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1858-D $5 NGC AU55 55 $6,000 10/24/22
HA 1858-D $5 AU55 NGC. Variety 43-II, 55 $3,055 09/12/16
HA 1858-D $5 AU55 NGC. Variety 43-HH, 55 $3,525 06/07/15
HA 1858-D $5 AU55 NGC. Variety 42-GG (formerly 35-CC). 55 $3,290 04/28/13
HA 1858-D $5 AU55 NGC. Variety 35-CC. The honey-gold surfaces of this Choice About Uncirculated coin have a few handling marks 55 $3,220 08/14/06
HA 1858-D $5 AU55 NGC. Variety 35-CC. Although it was the Civil War that ended production at Dahlonega, its future was already 55 $3,852 06/03/05
HA 1858-D $5 AU53 NGC. Variety 43-II. 53 $5,760 08/26/22
HA 1858-D $5 AU53 NGC. Variety 42-GG (formerly 35-CC). 53 $3,525 01/14/13
HA 1858-D $5 AU53 NGC. Variety 35-DD. 53 $4,600 07/15/12
HA 1858-D $5 AU53 NGC. Variety 35-CC. 53 $4,312 05/01/11
HA 1858-D $5 AU53 NGC. PCGS Population (9/43). NGC Census: (7/52). Mintage: 15,362. Numismedia Wsl. Price: $3,050. 53 $3,594 10/25/05
HA 1858-D $5 AU53 NGC. Variety 35-CC. Nicely struck, 53 $3,795 07/21/04
HA 1858-D $5 AU50 NGC. Variety 43-HH. 50 $2,520 07/12/19
HA 1858-D $5 AU50 NGC. Variety 43-HH. 50 $2,520 04/26/19
HA 1858-D $5 AU50 NGC. 50 $2,702 01/09/17
HA 1858-D $5 AU50 NGC. Variety 43-II. 50 $3,055 07/10/16
HA 1858-D $5 AU50 NGC. NGC Census: (6/68). PCGS Population (17/50). Mintage: 15,362. Numismedia Wsl. Price for NGC/PCGS coin i 50 $2,415 09/28/08
Legend $5 1858-D NGC AU58 CAC 58 $6,756 09/27/18
Legend $5 1858-D NGC AU58 CAC 58 $7,638 07/26/18
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. CAC. Variety 43-HH. 58 $7,800 04/27/18
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 43-II, 58 $4,935 04/26/15
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 43-HH. 58 $4,112 04/27/14
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. NGC Census: (38/8). PCGS Population (27/8). Mintage: 15,362. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC 58 $4,465 03/12/13
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 42-GG (formerly 35-CC). 58 $4,847 01/14/13
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. 58 $5,175 03/28/10
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1858-D $5 58 $5,750 05/25/08
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 35-DD, Large Mintmark. This pleasing piece is just a hair's breadth away from Mint State, with 58 $5,750 06/02/07
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 35-CC. Most examples found of this issue fall into the lower Extremely Fine or AU grades. Near- 58 $5,462 01/06/07
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. Variety 35-CC. Lustrous and nicely struck, although the upper right hair curls and the fletchings have 58 $6,900 12/14/05
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1858-D $5 58 $6,325 09/20/05
HA 1858-D $5 AU58 NGC. Winter 29-V, First Edition. The 1858- 58 $6,210 11/07/03
HA 1858-D $5 58 $4,888 02/12/99
HA 1858-D $5 58 $2,200 06/03/94
HA 1858-D $5 Fine 15 NGC. NGC Census: (2/115). PCGS Population: (1/127). Mintage 15,362. 15 $1,410 08/06/17
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1858-D $5 60 $4,484 06/01/14
HA 1858-D $5 MS60 NGC. Variety 35-DD. 60 $8,063 08/15/10
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1858-D $5 60 $7,475 02/01/09
HA 1858-D $5 MS61 NGC. Variety 43-HH. 61 $10,575 01/12/14
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1858-D $5 61 $11,788 02/05/06
HA 1858-D $5 MS61 NGC. Ex: Ashland City. Variety 35-DD. (per 61 $10,350 01/31/04
HA 1858-D $5 MS61 NGC. Winter 29-V. Only 15,362 pieces were 61 $10,350 01/11/03
HA 1858-D $5 VF30 NGC. Variety 35-DD. 30 $1,610 04/22/12
HA 1858-D $5 VF30 NGC. Variety 35-DD. 30 $1,545 07/10/11
HA 1858-D $5 VF35 NGC. Variety 35-CC. An elusive, late-date Dahlonega half eagle that is normally seen with weak central detai 35 $2,185 04/29/06
HA 1858-D $5 35 $1,092 01/07/00
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1858-D $5 NGC XF45 45 $2,530 07/21/04
NNP Encyclopedia data is provided in cooperation of Collectibles Technology Corporation (CTC) and CDN Publishing, LLC. NNP assumes no liability or accuracy of this data.

NNP is 100% non-profit and independent

Your feedback is essential and welcome