1858-S $5

CPG Values (What is CPG?)

Grade CPG Value
VG8 $1,380.00
VG10 $1,470.00
F12 $1,620.00
F15 $1,750.00
VF20 $2,000.00
VF25 $2,250.00
VF30 $3,000.00
VF35 $3,750.00
XF40 $5,000.00
XF45 $5,750.00
AU50 $6,750.00
AU53 $7,500.00
AU55 $9,500.00
AU58 $19,200.00
MS60 $33,600.00
MS61 $40,800.00
VG8 CAC $1,650.00
VG10 CAC $1,760.00
F12 CAC $1,950.00
F15 CAC $2,100.00
VF20 CAC $2,400.00
VF25 CAC $2,700.00
VF30 CAC $3,600.00
VF35 CAC $4,500.00
XF40 CAC $6,000.00
XF45 CAC $6,900.00
AU50 CAC $8,100.00
AU53 CAC $9,000.00
AU55 CAC $11,400.00
AU58 CAC $23,000.00
MS60 CAC $40,300.00

Apr Data

Auction House Description Grade Sell Price Sell Date
HA 1858-S $5 VG8 PCGS. CAC. Ex: The Fairmont Collection. CAC Population: (2/9). Mintage 18,600. 8 $2,040 11/24/24
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. VG-8 (PCGS). CAC. 8 $2,640 03/26/21
1858-S $5 VG8 PCGS. 8 $748 06/02/08
HA 1858-S $5 VG8 PCGS. This fairly worn specimen displays honey-gold surfaces imbued with traces of light green. The central 8 $920 04/29/06
HA 1858-S $5 VG8 PCGS. 8 $690 12/18/04
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. EF-45 (PCGS). 45 $5,040 11/21/23
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. EF-45 (PCGS). 45 $5,520 03/22/23
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. AU Details--Repaired (PCGS). 0 $3,600 08/23/23
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. VF-25 (PCGS). CAC. 25 $4,320 08/09/23
$5 1858-S PCGS AU55+ CAC 55 $16,450 04/27/23
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. AU-55 (PCGS). CAC. 55 $11,400 03/21/23
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. AU-55 (PCGS). CAC. 55 $12,600 08/23/22
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. AU-55 (PCGS). 55 $4,080 08/14/19
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. AU-50 (PCGS). CAC. 50 $7,200 11/02/22
HA 1858-S $5 50 $3,575 02/06/95
1858-S Liberty Head Half Eagle. AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. 58 $33,600 04/06/22
$5 1858-S PCGS AU58+ CAC 58 $39,950 10/28/21
1858-S $5 AU58+ PCGS. CAC. The 1858-S half eagle is an historic rarity among San Francisco gold issues from the 1850s. The 58 $21,600 12/30/20
1858-S $5 AU58 PCGS. 58 $12,500 12/02/12
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 PCGS. 58 $12,650 03/25/05
American Numismatic Rarities 1858-S $5 58 $12,650 01/05/04
1858-S $5 VF30 PCGS. CAC. 30 $2,350 08/04/17
Stacks Bowers 1858-S $5 30 $1,495 03/23/09
1858-S $5 AU53 PCGS. 53 $4,700 09/20/15
HA 1858-S $5 AU53 PCGS. Dark orange-gold throughout. The strike is average for this issue and the surfaces show moderate abras 53 $3,738 02/11/06
Superior 1858-S $5 53 $3,795 01/02/06
American Numismatic Rarities 1858-S $5 53 $4,600 03/09/04
1858-S Liberty Half Eagle. EF-40 (PCGS). OGH. 40 $4,487 03/15/13
1858-S $5 MS61 PCGS. 61 $28,878 08/03/08
HA 1858-S $5 15 $374 06/06/98
HA 1858-S $5 12 $352 02/05/94
HA 1858-S $5 XF45 NGC. 45 $3,960 11/22/24
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1858-S $5 45 $2,415 09/20/10
HA 1858-S $5 XF40 NGC. 40 $2,640 09/15/23
HA 1858-S $5 XF40 NGC. 40 $2,760 05/05/23
HA 1858-S $5 XF40 NGC. 40 $3,290 12/08/13
HA 1858-S $5 --Improperly Cleaned--NCS. XF Details. 40 $805 09/21/08
David Lawrence Rare Coins 1858-S $5 NGC XF40 40 $1,610 07/21/04
HA 1858-S $5 VF20 NGC. The low mintage and extensive commercial use make the 1858-S a rare San Francisco date. Most surviving 20 $1,680 02/06/22
HA 1858-S $5 VF20 NGC. NGC Census: (2/60). PCGS Population (1/31). Mintage: 18,600. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC 20 $1,035 01/18/11
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 NGC. 58 $7,800 10/15/20
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 NGC. 58 $8,400 06/04/20
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 NGC. 58 $7,800 12/05/19
HA 1858-S $5 AU58+ NGC. 58 $19,200 04/25/19
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 NGC. 58 $17,250 01/12/08
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 NGC. 58 $25,300 08/12/07
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 NGC. Although the mintage of 18,600 coins suggests that this should be a relatively plentiful date, that is 58 $11,500 02/17/07
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 NGC. NGC Census: (10/0). PCGS Population (3/0). Mintage: 18,600. Numismedia Wsl. Price: $12,500. (#8279) 58 $9,600 05/16/06
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 NGC. Well detailed with a pleasing, natural reddish patina over both sides. Field marks are numerous, as is 58 $8,625 01/07/06
HA 1858-S $5 AU58 NGC. The 1858-S half eagle is very scarce as a date, with a mintage of only 18,600 pieces. A few more that 8 58 $11,212 11/05/05
Stacks Bowers 1858-S $5 58 $11,500 06/23/04
HA 1858-S $5 58 $10,350 01/08/99
HA 1858-S $5 AU55 NGC. 55 $4,920 09/18/20
HA 1858-S $5 AU55 NGC. 55 $3,000 07/11/19
HA 1858-S $5 AU55 NGC. 55 $6,600 03/14/19
HA 1858-S $5 AU55 NGC. 55 $7,050 03/20/14
HA 1858-S $5 AU55 NGC. 55 $5,462 08/02/09
HA 1858-S $5 MS60 NGC. 60 $21,600 07/12/18
HA 1858-S $5 AU50 NGC. 50 $3,290 01/09/17
HA 1858-S $5 -- Removed From Jewelry -- NCS. AU Details. NGC Census: (8/25). PCGS Population (3/14). Mintage: 18,600. Numismed 50 $1,087 04/27/14
Stacks Bowers 1858-S Liberty Half Eagle. AU-50 (NGC). 50 $4,487 11/08/13
Ira & Larry Goldberg 1858-S $5 50 $3,795 02/02/13
HA 1858-S $5 AU50 NGC. 50 $3,450 06/03/12
HA 1858-S $5 50 $2,990 08/13/99
HA 1858-S $5 50 $3,630 10/04/95
HA 1858-S $5 AU53 NGC. 53 $4,230 09/12/16
Stacks Bowers 1858-S Liberty Half Eagle. AU-53 (NGC). 53 $4,432 08/10/12
HA 1858-S $5 AU53 NGC. 53 $4,312 01/08/12
HA 1858-S $5 AU53 NGC. NGC Census: (10/21). PCGS Population (1/10). Mintage: 18,600. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NG 53 $4,744 09/06/11
HA 1858-S $5 53 $4,042 10/05/94
HA 1858-S $5 VG10 NGC. NGC Census: (2/54). PCGS Population (0/36). Mintage: 18,600. Numismedia Wsl. Price for problem free NGC 10 $1,234 04/07/15
Stacks Bowers 1858-S Liberty Half Eagle. AU Details--Improperly Cleaned (NGC). 0 $1,933 05/10/13
HA 1858-S $5 F15 NGC. NGC Census: (1/57). PCGS Population (1/28). Mintage: 18,600. Numismedia Wsl. Price for NGC/PCGS coin in 15 $805 07/12/09
HA 1858-S $5 F15 NGC. NGC Census: (1/55). PCGS Population (1/25). Mintage: 18,600. Numismedia Wsl. Price for NGC/PCGS coin in 15 $978 01/16/08
NNP Encyclopedia data is provided in cooperation of Collectibles Technology Corporation (CTC) and CDN Publishing, LLC. NNP assumes no liability or accuracy of this data.

NNP is 100% non-profit and independent

Your feedback is essential and welcome